Why Can't They Leave Good Movies Alone? A Dive into Remakes
In today's entertainment landscape, remakes have become a staple of Hollywood's content strategy. This trend has sparked debates among viewers about creativity, nostalgia, and whether these reimaginings ever truly capture the magic of the originals. The Girl Gang recently tackled this thorny subject, diving deep into what makes remakes work—and what makes them fail spectacularly. We started out the discussion by determining what the differences are between a remake, a sequel, and a reboot and dove in from there.
The inspiration for this episode came from us seeing the new live-action remake of "How to Train Your Dragon," which we believe is a rare remake that actually succeeded. What made this particular adaptation stand out was the director's devotion to preserving the original character designs, especially Toothless. In a revealing interview, director Dean DeBlois explained how he refused to alter Toothless's appearance to make him more "realistic," understanding that the character's magical qualities and distinctive features were integral to the audience's connection with him. This preservation of the original's spirit while updating the format represents what many viewers wish all remakes would prioritize.
By contrast, Disney's growing catalog of live-action remakes received mixed reviews from the hosts. While "Beauty and the Beast" earned praise, films like "The Lion King" and "Mulan" were criticized for either feeling unnecessary or for making substantial changes that alienated fans of the originals. The "Mulan" remake, in particular, drew criticism for removing beloved elements like the songs and Mushu's character while attempting to create a more historically accurate version—a change that many viewers weren't seeking in a Disney adaptation.
Time and adaptation approach also emerged as key factors in remake success. The hosts discussed how some remakes work better when significant time has passed between versions. Films like "Ocean's Eleven" and "Scarface" are successful remakes that many viewers don't even realize are remakes because enough time has passed for the new version to stand on its own. Similarly, adaptations like "Ever After" and "Ella Enchanted," which take the Cinderella story in new directions rather than attempting to replicate the Disney version, received praise for their creative approaches.
The conversation extended beyond individual films to question the larger motivation behind Hollywood's remake frenzy. The hosts speculated that financial considerations, rather than artistic ones, drive most remake decisions. As one host bluntly put it, "Money speaks louder than art." This economic reality explains why studios continue producing remakes despite mixed critical reception—they're reliable revenue generators based on pre-existing intellectual property with built-in audiences.
Several remakes were highlighted as particularly successful, including "The Italian Job" with Mark Wahlberg, which one host grew up watching with her grandfather because of their shared love of Mini Coopers. These personal connections reveal how remakes can bridge generational gaps and create new memories around familiar stories.
Casting emerged as another crucial element in remake success, with the hosts noting that well-cast actors can sometimes elevate otherwise mediocre remakes. They cited the "Footloose" remake as an example of "well-casted, poorly executed"—featuring talented performers like Julianne Hough but failing to capture the magic of the original.
As Hollywood continues to mine its back catalog for remake opportunities, viewers are becoming increasingly discerning about which ones deserve their time and money. The conversation concluded with the us wondering if audiences have reached "superhero movie fatigue" and whether the same might soon happen with remakes more broadly. Perhaps the most telling sentiment came in the form of a simple guideline for studios: "If it ain't broken, don't fuck with it." This colorful advice encapsulates what many viewers feel—some classics simply don't need reinvention.
Listen Now!
We hope you enjoyed this episode of Girl Gang Podcast. What movie remakes to you like? Which ones should be left alone? Text us with the link in our episode description!
So until next time - stay bold, stay empowered…
Rachael & the Girl Gang
